Doe · awareness doors · one ad per stage

Seedance swap on donor footage, product-only reference, a Black woman recast by words, Seedance voices; the hook sticker, the before/after pair, the product cutout and the house captions burned by us after the take. Redub pass for the mispronounced words still to run (esthetician, glycolic, melanin, bergamot, insecure).

Door A · PROBLEM AWARE

Valley: it is just my skin, I was born with it

hook: Brooke Thompson advertorial; body: donor 09 (celinesfavoritefinds), the same-product swap that cleared cash

85 s · the before/after lands on lighter at 7.26s · verdict: 4 fatal, 54 major, 33 minor (read it)

0.1s fatal editing: the word "Three" (0.00-0.22 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +11.0 dB inside it
18.2s fatal editing: the word "because" (17.94-18.28 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +22.5 dB inside it
84.1s fatal editing: the word "especially" (83.86-84.26 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +17.9 dB inside it
45.2s fatal continuity: the shot from 45.2s to 46.73s is dressed differently from the rest of the ad: torso colour correlation 0.524 against the other shots, measured over 14 frames. The donor's own least consistent shot measures 0.639 and the
38.3s major speech: SHE SAYS "menahin" WHERE THE SCRIPT SAYS "melanin". A viewer hears the wrong line; fix by redubbing that line in her own cloned voice (a-mispronounced-brand-is-redubbed-not-regenerated)
47.6s major speech: SHE SAYS "dough" WHERE THE SCRIPT SAYS "doe". A viewer hears the wrong line; fix by redubbing that line in her own cloned voice (a-mispronounced-brand-is-redubbed-not-regenerated)
68.0s major deadair: DEAD AIR: she stops talking for 0.72 s after "day." (68.00-68.72 s) while the picture keeps running; the picture cuts at 68.73 s inside the gap. A viewer sees her move with nothing said; trim the tail or fill the line
80.6s major deadair: DEAD AIR: she stops talking for 0.86 s after "desert." (80.56-81.42 s) while the picture keeps running; the picture cuts at 81.30 s inside the gap. A viewer sees her move with nothing said; trim the tail or fill the line
14.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The armpit comparison overlay at the top of the screen vanishes instantly with no fade, animation or transition - it simply stops existing in the frame with no warning.
14.9s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Hard unmotivated jump cut: the entire background changes instantly. The ceiling fan present for the first 5 seconds vanishes completely, replaced by a blank wall. Camera framing also shif
30.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Jarring hard cut opens the clip: the prior shot cut off mid-speech, this shot begins with no transition, the woman's position and framing jump abruptly with zero continuity. Audio cuts cl
30.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Abrupt unmotivated cut: the shot changes instantly with no transition, background, framing, and held object all change discontinuously mid-speech flow. The product appears in her hand out
45.2s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Hard cut where the woman's clothing instantly changes from white tank top to cream halter top, a necklace appears out of nowhere, and new background items appear with zero transition. The
50.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's entire raised left arm disappears instantly between frames with no motion or transition; one frame it is held overhead, the next it is repositioned down gesturing normally
66.6s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): With no cut or movement explaining it, the woman's tank top shoulder strap instantly changes colour and material from solid white to pale green textured fabric
7.4s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The armpit overlay clip pops in abruptly with no fade or transition, then just as abruptly disappears at 9.8s
23.5s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "if" (23.44-23.66 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
30.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Lighting and skin tone change abruptly across the cut without cause; the woman's skin colour and scene lighting are inconsistent between the two shots.
46.7s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "double" (46.64-46.84 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
56.2s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "tone" (56.14-56.36 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
66.5s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "and" (66.44-66.64 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
66.9s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "bergamot" (66.64-66.98 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
76.1s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "gonna" (76.00-76.10 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
40.7s major action: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's eyes jump instantly and unnaturally upwards off-camera with no smooth movement, in a motion impossible for a real human.
46.0s major action: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman pretends to apply deodorant but never makes actual contact between the deodorant stick and her armpit skin; she only waves the object nearby with no real rubbing motion.
75.7s major action: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Deodorant cap detaches unnaturally: it pops free without matching twisting hand motion, no physical resistance is shown.
33.1s major physics: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Despite rubbing the solid deodorant stick repeatedly directly onto her forearm skin, absolutely no product residue, mark, or transfer appears on the skin at all. The stick also wobbles un
56.8s major physics: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Ceiling fan blades teleport position abruptly: the fan blade alignment jumps instantly between frames instead of rotating smoothly
6.6s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): When the woman first raises her hand to gesture, the visible fingers are distorted, blurry, incorrectly shaped and do not look like real human fingers
30.1s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The right hand holding the product has broken anatomy: there are extra, misformed fingers, distorted digit shapes, and inconsistent unnatural nail positions on the visible hand.
33.0s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The curled left hand at the woman's wrist has malformed, fused, distorted fingers that do not match human anatomy; digits are merged incorrectly and shaped unnaturally.
61.8s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's left gesturing hand has distorted extra merged fingers that do not match human anatomy
74.3s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Both hands holding the deodorant have distorted, merged and extra visible fingers while twisting the cap; digits do not look human.
10.9s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's hand appears unnaturally as it enters frame: it pops into view without smooth motion, and the visible fingers are distorted, blurry, and do not match normal human hand anatomy
15.5s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): As the woman gestures, her moving hands have malformed, unstable fingers: individual fingers appear and disappear between frames, shape warps unnaturally, and edges stay incorrectly blurr
20.7s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): When the woman gestures, her hands appear unnaturally distorted: fingers are blurred, count is wrong, and the hands warp unnaturally as they move at the bottom of the frame.
38.0s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Nails on the woman's gesturing left hand are unnaturally warped, misshapen, overly elongated with wrong proportions unlike real human nails.
47.8s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Unnatural rigid horizontal distorted lines appear frozen across the woman's forehead; they do not move or deform correctly with her facial expressions.
48.8s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The fingers on the hand holding the deodorant are malformed: nail shapes are broken, edges are distorted, and finger proportions are wrong.
51.8s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Left hand fingernails repeatedly change length, design and shape between consecutive frames; white tip edges, black line details and nail length shift without cause
64.5s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The length and shape of the woman's fingernails on her holding hand change unnaturally between consecutive frames
69.2s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's left hand raised above her head has merged, incorrectly counted fingers
70.9s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Right hand applying deodorant has warped fingers: the gold ring appears to incorrectly float across multiple fingers.
82.4s major anatomy: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The left index finger pointing at the product has distorted, unnatural anatomy and a misshapen nail
11.3s major overlay: BODY OVERLAY (before_after) IS NOT HERS: no source_frame inside this ad names the presenter frame it was made from. Fix: make the pair from a frame of this ad and name it in the plan
81.7s major other: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The blue deodorant cap in the woman's left hand is incorrectly fused/clipping through her finger, it does not appear to be properly held as a separate object
0.0s major overlay: STICKER A-aha.png: too large: 0.91 of the width and 0.10 of the height (caps 0.85 and 0.32, swipe median width 54%); outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.07 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header), left (x
0.1s major audio-seam: the track steps +11.0 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
7.3s major overlay: OVERLAY now-A.png: outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.03 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header). Fix: move or resize it in the plan and re-render
7.7s major other: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The arm/armpit in the overlay has unnaturally smoothed skin, a warped edge where the arm meets the tank top, and looks obviously AI generated
11.3s major overlay: OVERLAY pair-A.png: outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.03 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header). Fix: move or resize it in the plan and re-render
15.0s major audio-seam: SEAM CLICK at the cut at 15.033s: click at 15.0406s, click at 15.0407s, discontinuity at 15.0407s (jump 0.4301). Fix: a 10 ms crossfade across the join
18.2s major audio-seam: the track steps +22.5 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
54.0s major audio-seam: the track steps +16.8 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
60.3s major audio-seam: the track steps +9.1 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
60.3s major audio-seam: SEAM CLICK at the cut at 60.267s: click at 60.2985s, click at 60.2986s, click at 60.2987s. Fix: a 10 ms crossfade across the join
83.7s major audio-seam: the track steps -22.0 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
84.1s major audio-seam: the track steps +17.9 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level

Door B · PROBLEM AWARE

Valley: it is normal, stop selling me a fix

hook: LivinWild advertorial A8; body: LivinWild + Miravelle beats on donor 03 footage

70 s · the before/after lands on mine at 4.82s · verdict: 10 fatal, 44 major, 21 minor (read it)

5.8s fatal editing: the word "especially" (5.54-5.96 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +13.9 dB inside it
11.0s fatal editing: the word "to..." (10.94-11.30 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps -11.9 dB inside it
11.3s fatal editing: the word "to..." (10.94-11.30 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +11.5 dB inside it
25.5s fatal editing: the word "exactly..." (25.22-25.92 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +9.3 dB inside it
45.6s fatal editing: the word "So" (45.58-45.72 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +13.8 dB inside it
47.6s fatal editing: the word "That" (47.52-47.66 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +14.8 dB inside it
48.1s fatal identity: the face in the shot from 48.13s to 49.4s does not match the rest of the ad: SFace cosine 0.432 against the other shots (every labelled control sits above 0.82)
56.0s fatal editing: the word "because" (55.80-56.14 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +26.6 dB inside it
60.3s fatal editing: the word "I" (60.18-60.36 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +14.4 dB inside it
65.7s fatal editing: the word "I'll" (65.64-65.82 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +28.4 dB inside it
0.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Clip starts abruptly mid-speech and mid-gesture, no opening lead-in, hands are cut off at the very first frame
0.2s major text: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Text overlay pops in instantly with zero fade/transition, appears jarringly out of nowhere at the top of frame
3.2s major text: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Opening top text vanishes abruptly with no transition, instantly disappears mid-sentence
3.4s major text: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): New text is placed incorrectly low, overlapping directly over the speaker's nose and mouth instead of a clean screen position
5.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Underarm comparison thumbnail images pop in abruptly floating at top left, appear completely unprompted with no gesture, animation or context leading to them
7.2s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The floating underarm images vanish instantly for no reason, mid-speech with no trigger action
21.0s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Abrupt untransitioned jump cut: camera framing, woman's head position, and background wall lighting shift instantly between shots with no smooth cut
25.8s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Extremely jarring hard cut: entire background room changes, lighting darkens drastically, woman's hair style and tank top fit shift instantly with zero transition
31.1s major lipsync: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Speaker's mouth stops moving entirely while spoken audio continues playing over the still face
40.8s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Extremely abrupt hard cut: background wall, hair pose, and hand position all jump instantly with no transition or natural movement. Audio also cuts harshly here.
40.9s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Harsh unmotivated hard cut: mid-smile the shot jumps instantly to a completely different framing holding a product with no transition
49.7s major physics: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Impossible physics: the woman's fingertips clip directly through the solid plastic deodorant bottle while she twists the cap, with solid objects intersecting.
53.4s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Extremely obvious untransitioned hard cut: background wall colour, lighting, camera framing, and the woman's entire upper body position all jump instantly between shots with no fade or cu
60.1s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Deodorant cap vanishes instantly between frames. No hand movement to remove it exists, the cap disappears entirely in one cut. This is immediately obvious.
0.0s major identity: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Unnaturally uniform glossy plastic-like shine across chest and neck, this is not real human skin/sweat, it is characteristic of bad AI generated skin rendering
3.0s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "magically" (2.62-3.12 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
4.2s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Another jump cut: hair curls shift position, head angle snaps, and skin lighting changes unnaturally between adjacent frames
5.8s major audio-seam: the track steps +13.9 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
11.0s major audio-seam: the track steps -11.9 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
11.3s major audio-seam: the track steps +11.5 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
22.0s major action: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Woman's right hand pops into the bottom edge of the frame abruptly with no natural leading motion
25.5s major audio-seam: the track steps +9.3 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
25.9s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "exactly..." (25.22-25.92 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
29.4s major action: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Hand teleport glitch: the woman's gesturing hand shifts position unnaturally across one frame with no continuous movement
40.9s major audio-seam: the track steps +18.5 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
41.0s major lipsync: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Broken lip sync immediately after the cut: the woman's mouth is already mid-speech shape at the very start of this shot, and does not align with the start of the spoken line.
43.4s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Continuity error: the blue deodorant stick completely vanishes then reappears in the woman's hand between cuts, with no movement showing her picking it back up.
45.6s major audio-seam: the track steps +13.8 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
47.6s major audio-seam: the track steps +14.8 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
47.7s major other: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Printed text on the deodorant bottle warps unnaturally: letters distort, stretch and mis-shape incorrectly as the object is moved, this is a clear AI rendering artifact.
48.1s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "led" (47.88-48.18 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
49.4s major audio-seam: the track steps +31.3 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
50.6s major physics: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Unnaturally fast, non-human hand motion: her fingers twist the cap far quicker and smoother than a real person can move
51.4s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Single frame jump error: the deodorant cap vanishes completely for 1 frame mid-pull gesture, then reappears
55.3s major lipsync: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Lip sync failure: the spoken word 'niacinamide' does not match her mouth shapes at all. Her lips are not forming the correct syllables for this word
56.0s major audio-seam: the track steps +26.6 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
57.9s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "perfect" (57.76-58.14 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
60.3s major audio-seam: the track steps +14.4 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
61.6s major text: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): On-screen caption changes early. New text appears while the speaker is still actively saying the prior line of dialogue.
61.7s major editing: the picture changes inside the spoken word "becoming" (61.48-61.82 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken.
62.5s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Right hand motion skips frames. The hand teleports half-way up to her head, with all intermediate movement frames missing.
65.7s major audio-seam: the track steps +28.4 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level
65.8s major editing: SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Right arm jumps instantly into the downward pointing pose. No smooth motion exists to move the hand into this position, it appears there out of nowhere.
67.2s major audio-seam: the track steps -8.5 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level

Door C · SOLUTION AWARE

Valley: I tried everything and stronger made it worse

hook: Smooche brow ad (family B); aha: Miravelle esthetician; body: donor 12 (vanilla_swirlxx) rant

94 s · the before/after lands on everything at 4.34s · verdict: 0 fatal, 0 major, 7 minor (read it)

no fatal or major finding