# Review — A-final 4 fatal · 54 major · 33 minor · 10 cosmetic · 25 measured but NOT judged engines: {"measure": {"cuts": 23, "shots": 21, "findings": 37}, "speech": {"findings": 4, "script": true}, "say": {"scored": 40, "worst": [["actually", 0.17], ["irritation", 0.29], ["response", 0.31], ["irritating", 0.33], ["especially", 0.33]]}, "caption": {"events": 59, "ocr_calls": 73, "coverage": 0.956, "errors": 0, "sync": {"median_lag_s": -0.03, "events": 59, "p90_abs": 0.26600000000000007}}, "overlay": {"boxes": 15, "undeclared": 0, "expected": 3}, "fit": {"devices": 3, "pacing": {"devices": 3, "per_minute": 2.1, "coverage": 0.094}, "major": 3}, "pair": {"body_overlays": 1, "not_hers": 1}, "click": {"clicks": 9, "discontinuities": 1, "seams_hit": 2, "elsewhere": 1}, "sweep": {"findings": 67, "fps": 5, "window_s": 11.0, "verified": 53, "confirmed": 40, "refuted": 10}} | At | Kind | Severity | What | |---|---|---|---| | 0.133s | editing | fatal | the word "Three" (0.00-0.22 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +11.0 dB inside it | | 18.167s | editing | fatal | the word "because" (17.94-18.28 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +22.5 dB inside it | | 84.067s | editing | fatal | the word "especially" (83.86-84.26 s) is cut in half: the picture changes AND the track steps +17.9 dB inside it | | 45.2s | continuity | fatal | the shot from 45.2s to 46.73s is dressed differently from the rest of the ad: torso colour correlation 0.524 against the other shots, measured over 14 frames. The donor's own least consistent shot measures 0.639 and the take Kalp rejected for its top measured 0.374. | | 38.34s | speech | major | SHE SAYS "menahin" WHERE THE SCRIPT SAYS "melanin". A viewer hears the wrong line; fix by redubbing that line in her own cloned voice (a-mispronounced-brand-is-redubbed-not-regenerated) | | 47.56s | speech | major | SHE SAYS "dough" WHERE THE SCRIPT SAYS "doe". A viewer hears the wrong line; fix by redubbing that line in her own cloned voice (a-mispronounced-brand-is-redubbed-not-regenerated) | | 68.0s | deadair | major | DEAD AIR: she stops talking for 0.72 s after "day." (68.00-68.72 s) while the picture keeps running; the picture cuts at 68.73 s inside the gap. A viewer sees her move with nothing said; trim the tail or fill the line | | 80.56s | deadair | major | DEAD AIR: she stops talking for 0.86 s after "desert." (80.56-81.42 s) while the picture keeps running; the picture cuts at 81.30 s inside the gap. A viewer sees her move with nothing said; trim the tail or fill the line | | 14.0s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The armpit comparison overlay at the top of the screen vanishes instantly with no fade, animation or transition - it simply stops existing in the frame with no warning. | | 14.9s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Hard unmotivated jump cut: the entire background changes instantly. The ceiling fan present for the first 5 seconds vanishes completely, replaced by a blank wall. Camera framing also shifts abruptly with no pan, transition or cut indication. | | 30.0s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Jarring hard cut opens the clip: the prior shot cut off mid-speech, this shot begins with no transition, the woman's position and framing jump abruptly with zero continuity. Audio cuts cleanly with no natural gap or room tone between shots. | | 30.0s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Abrupt unmotivated cut: the shot changes instantly with no transition, background, framing, and held object all change discontinuously mid-speech flow. The product appears in her hand out of nowhere with no prior action of picking it up shown. | | 45.2s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Hard cut where the woman's clothing instantly changes from white tank top to cream halter top, a necklace appears out of nowhere, and new background items appear with zero transition. The spoken audio continues perfectly seamlessly across this cut which is physically impossible for real filmed footage. | | 50.0s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's entire raised left arm disappears instantly between frames with no motion or transition; one frame it is held overhead, the next it is repositioned down gesturing normally | | 66.6s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): With no cut or movement explaining it, the woman's tank top shoulder strap instantly changes colour and material from solid white to pale green textured fabric | | 7.4s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The armpit overlay clip pops in abruptly with no fade or transition, then just as abruptly disappears at 9.8s | | 23.533s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "if" (23.44-23.66 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 30.0s | editing | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Lighting and skin tone change abruptly across the cut without cause; the woman's skin colour and scene lighting are inconsistent between the two shots. | | 46.733s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "double" (46.64-46.84 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 56.167s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "tone" (56.14-56.36 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 66.5s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "and" (66.44-66.64 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 66.933s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "bergamot" (66.64-66.98 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 76.067s | editing | major | the picture changes inside the spoken word "gonna" (76.00-76.10 s). The track runs on through it, so the line is whole and the EDIT lands mid-word, which reads as clumsy rather than broken. | | 40.7s | action | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's eyes jump instantly and unnaturally upwards off-camera with no smooth movement, in a motion impossible for a real human. | | 46.0s | action | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman pretends to apply deodorant but never makes actual contact between the deodorant stick and her armpit skin; she only waves the object nearby with no real rubbing motion. | | 75.7s | action | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Deodorant cap detaches unnaturally: it pops free without matching twisting hand motion, no physical resistance is shown. | | 33.1s | physics | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Despite rubbing the solid deodorant stick repeatedly directly onto her forearm skin, absolutely no product residue, mark, or transfer appears on the skin at all. The stick also wobbles unnaturally as if not solidly gripped. | | 56.8s | physics | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Ceiling fan blades teleport position abruptly: the fan blade alignment jumps instantly between frames instead of rotating smoothly | | 6.6s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): When the woman first raises her hand to gesture, the visible fingers are distorted, blurry, incorrectly shaped and do not look like real human fingers | | 30.1s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The right hand holding the product has broken anatomy: there are extra, misformed fingers, distorted digit shapes, and inconsistent unnatural nail positions on the visible hand. | | 33.0s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The curled left hand at the woman's wrist has malformed, fused, distorted fingers that do not match human anatomy; digits are merged incorrectly and shaped unnaturally. | | 61.8s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's left gesturing hand has distorted extra merged fingers that do not match human anatomy | | 74.3s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Both hands holding the deodorant have distorted, merged and extra visible fingers while twisting the cap; digits do not look human. | | 10.9s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's hand appears unnaturally as it enters frame: it pops into view without smooth motion, and the visible fingers are distorted, blurry, and do not match normal human hand anatomy. | | 15.5s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): As the woman gestures, her moving hands have malformed, unstable fingers: individual fingers appear and disappear between frames, shape warps unnaturally, and edges stay incorrectly blurred even on slow movements. | | 20.7s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): When the woman gestures, her hands appear unnaturally distorted: fingers are blurred, count is wrong, and the hands warp unnaturally as they move at the bottom of the frame. | | 38.0s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Nails on the woman's gesturing left hand are unnaturally warped, misshapen, overly elongated with wrong proportions unlike real human nails. | | 47.8s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Unnatural rigid horizontal distorted lines appear frozen across the woman's forehead; they do not move or deform correctly with her facial expressions. | | 48.8s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The fingers on the hand holding the deodorant are malformed: nail shapes are broken, edges are distorted, and finger proportions are wrong. | | 51.8s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Left hand fingernails repeatedly change length, design and shape between consecutive frames; white tip edges, black line details and nail length shift without cause | | 64.5s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The length and shape of the woman's fingernails on her holding hand change unnaturally between consecutive frames | | 69.2s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The woman's left hand raised above her head has merged, incorrectly counted fingers | | 70.9s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Right hand applying deodorant has warped fingers: the gold ring appears to incorrectly float across multiple fingers. | | 82.4s | anatomy | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The left index finger pointing at the product has distorted, unnatural anatomy and a misshapen nail | | 11.35s | overlay | major | BODY OVERLAY (before_after) IS NOT HERS: no source_frame inside this ad names the presenter frame it was made from. Fix: make the pair from a frame of this ad and name it in the plan | | 81.7s | other | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The blue deodorant cap in the woman's left hand is incorrectly fused/clipping through her finger, it does not appear to be properly held as a separate object | | 0.0s | overlay | major | STICKER A-aha.png: too large: 0.91 of the width and 0.10 of the height (caps 0.85 and 0.32, swipe median width 54%); outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.07 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header), left (x 0.04 < 0.11), right (x+w 0.96 > 0.82, the like/share rail). Fix: move or resize it in the plan and re-render | | 0.133s | audio-seam | major | the track steps +11.0 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 7.26s | overlay | major | OVERLAY now-A.png: outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.03 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header). Fix: move or resize it in the plan and re-render | | 7.7s | other | major | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The arm/armpit in the overlay has unnaturally smoothed skin, a warped edge where the arm meets the tank top, and looks obviously AI generated | | 11.35s | overlay | major | OVERLAY pair-A.png: outside the platform safe zone on the top (y 0.03 < 0.15, under the TikTok and Shorts header). Fix: move or resize it in the plan and re-render | | 15.033s | audio-seam | major | SEAM CLICK at the cut at 15.033s: click at 15.0406s, click at 15.0407s, discontinuity at 15.0407s (jump 0.4301). Fix: a 10 ms crossfade across the join | | 18.167s | audio-seam | major | the track steps +22.5 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 53.967s | audio-seam | major | the track steps +16.8 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 60.267s | audio-seam | major | the track steps +9.1 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 60.267s | audio-seam | major | SEAM CLICK at the cut at 60.267s: click at 60.2985s, click at 60.2986s, click at 60.2987s. Fix: a 10 ms crossfade across the join | | 83.733s | audio-seam | major | the track steps -22.0 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 84.067s | audio-seam | major | the track steps +17.9 dB at this cut with speech running on both sides of it, which is heard as a jump in level | | 0.0s | editing | minor | SWEEP (unverified): The clip starts abruptly, with the woman already mid-word and mid-sentence as the video begins | | 11.4s | editing | minor | SWEEP (unverified): The armpit comparison overlay appears abruptly with zero transition, popping into existence at the top of the frame without animation. | | 23.533s | editing | minor | the cut lands 93 ms after the word "So" ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 46.733s | editing | minor | the cut lands 93 ms after the word "that" ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 50.2s | editing | minor | the cut lands 80 ms after the word "that." ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 53.967s | editing | minor | the cut lands 87 ms after the word "it." ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 56.167s | editing | minor | the cut lands 27 ms after the word "skin" ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 66.5s | editing | minor | the cut lands 60 ms after the word "vanilla" ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 68.8s | editing | minor | SWEEP (unverified): When moving to apply deodorant, the woman's arm teleports/jumps into the raised position with no smooth motion between frames | | 73.333s | editing | minor | the cut lands 73 ms after the word "you." ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 76.067s | editing | minor | the cut lands 67 ms after the word "I'm" ends, so the line has no tail before the shot changes | | 18.6s | lipsync | minor | SWEEP (unverified): Lip sync desync: the woman's mouth shape, movement timing and opening size do not match the spoken dialogue about baking soda and alcohol. | | 57.9s | lipsync | minor | SWEEP (unverified): Lip sync failure: the woman's mouth is closed while the spoken audio line 'to help even it out' is playing, mouth shape does not match speech sounds | | 17.2s | physics | minor | SWEEP (unverified): While gesturing, the woman's hands partially clip through the fabric of her tank top unnaturally, rather than resting correctly on the outside of the clothing. | | 73.2s | physics | minor | SWEEP (unverified): Ceiling fan in the background is completely frozen static, blades do not rotate despite appearing to be an installed active room fan. | | 77.4s | anatomy | minor | SWEEP (frames inconclusive): Left hand holding the deodorant cap has warped misshapen fingers and unnatural distorted fingernails. | | 10.9s | anatomy | minor | SWEEP (frames inconclusive): When the woman gestures again at the end of the clip, the visible hand fingers are warped, misshapen, and have an incorrect count | | 37.5s | anatomy | minor | SWEEP (frames inconclusive): After the cut, the right hand holding the deodorant now has extra, misaligned, warped fingers that were not present on the same hand earlier in the clip. | | 54.2s | anatomy | minor | SWEEP (unverified): An extra partial malformed finger appears on the woman's left hand while gesturing near the deodorant; finger count and alignment are wrong | | 83.8s | anatomy | minor | SWEEP (unverified): An extra distorted partial finger edge is visible on the right hand holding the deodorant stick | | 30.1s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The printed text on the deodorant product is broken: characters are warped, illegible, shift and morph incorrectly between frames, and do not form consistent readable words. | | 45.7s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The printed brand label text on the deodorant breaks completely: it warps into distorted, non-alphabet nonsense symbols, and shifts incorrectly as the product is moved. | | 50.0s | product | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The deodorant product label completely changes instantly: first it shows warped backwards nonsense characters, then immediately becomes clean readable 'Bright Days' text with no movement or rotation to explain the change | | 84.1s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The printed text label on the deodorant bottle unnaturally warps, distorts and changes letter shapes while the bottle is held still | | 3.2s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): The upper on-screen caption text vanishes instantly and completely mid-speech with no transition, for no visible reason | | 65.1s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Printed text on the deodorant product warps; letters on the label shift shape and legibility without the product moving | | 69.7s | product | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): While applying the deodorant, the white roll-on top of the product disappears entirely for one frame then reappears | | 74.6s | text | minor | SWEEP (confirmed on the frames): Text printed on the deodorant bottle warps, distorts, and shifts incorrectly as the bottle is rotated; letters misalign and appear illegible. | | 30.2s | product | minor | SWEEP (unverified): Printed text on the deodorant packaging is blurred, warped, and has incorrectly formed letters; brand and product name text is distorted, not matching real printed product labels. | | 30.2s | other | minor | SWEEP (unverified): The ceiling fan in the background is completely frozen static with no rotation, motion blur, or movement, unlike a normal functioning ceiling fan in an occupied room. | | 40.7s | text | minor | SWEEP (unverified): On-screen text cuts off mid-sentence with broken unfinished grammar: "which is why so many of the products" ends incorrectly with no completion. | | 79.8s | product | minor | SWEEP (unverified): Uncapped deodorant roller top is uneven, lumpy and misshapen, not a smooth uniform round roller as manufactured deodorant has. | | 81.0s | text | minor | SWEEP (unverified): The on-screen caption line vanishes slightly before the speaker finishes saying the corresponding spoken words | | 50.3s | editing | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): Abrupt hard cut back: the woman's clothing instantly snaps back to the original white tank top, the necklace vanishes, and camera framing jumps unnaturally. Again audio continues flawlessly across the cut. | | 71.7s | editing | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): Abrupt hard cut: the underarm rubbing motion stops mid-stroke, jumps instantly to the woman holding the deodorant at her face with no natural movement transition. | | 59.1s | editing | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): Hard jump cut mid-speech: the woman's head position, facial expression and shoulder angle shift discontinuously while she is mid-sentence, with no natural motion transition | | 78.6s | lipsync | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): Lip sync mismatch: audio pronounces the word 'sweating' while the woman's mouth is closed and not moving for this syllable. | | 80.3s | physics | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): One blade of the ceiling fan abruptly vanishes from frame without any matching spinning motion to explain this | | 30.0s | anatomy | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): The right hand holding the deodorant is missing a thumb, only 4 total fingers are visible with no plausible position the thumb could be hidden. | | 53.5s | identity | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): The woman's nose ring vanishes and reappears across cuts; her hoop earring also changes size and position discontinuously | | 63.2s | continuity | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): A gold ring suddenly appears on the woman's right hand with no action that would put it there, it was not present in all preceding frames | | 10.0s | text | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): First on-screen caption contains a duplicated typo error: the phrase 'is kind of crazy' is incorrectly repeated twice in the line of text. | | 50.2s | continuity | cosmetic | SWEEP (the frame check disagreed, read it yourself): The woman's necklace pendant changes shape instantly: it was a small square charm, then abruptly becomes a dark butterfly shaped charm with no movement that would flip or change the visible pendant | | 0s | lipsync | unknown | sync NOT judged: peak MFCC R2 0.072 is below the 0.15 floor every control cleared, so the mouth is not readable here; best lag -33 ms; loudness correlation 0.019 at zero lag, best 0.092 at -267 ms, 203 frames loud-with-closed-mouth, 38 open-over-silence, NOT judged (the donor reads 0.087 / 26 / 1); LipLeak 0.5 | | 11.35s | skin-tone | unknown | BODY OVERLAY skin a*b* (132.3, 139.9) vs the presenter's cheek (135.6, 134.1): distance 6.6 (a*-3.3, b*+5.8), reported only until an accepted pair is measured | | 0s | cadence | unknown | CADENCE, for the eye only: the first 10 s carry 1 visible change(s), one every 5.0 s; the general lean in short-form is one every 1-2 s. The whole ad runs one every 3.6 s. A yapper or an older audience wants longer holds, so this is case by case and never a defect. | | 0s | caption | unknown | CAPTION SYNC, reported only: median -0.03 s from the first spoken word to the caption appearing over 59 events (90th percentile 0.27 s); the correct cut reads +0.00 / 0.19 and unshifted controls read -0.24 to -0.29, so no verdict is drawn | | 0s | text | unknown | OTHER ON-SCREEN TEXT, read for a human: Bright / Days | | 0.13s | skin-tone | unknown | skin NOT JUDGED: the shot from 0.13s to 10.7s sits a*-1.8 b*-4.3 from the other shots (distance 6.1). The donor reaches 7.1 at its own cuts, so this scale cannot separate a light change from a skin change. A human decides; positive a* and b* together read as warmer and more yellow. | | 26.92s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "deodorant" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "gular dioteren" (overlap 0.47). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 30.1s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps +15.9 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 33.0s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps +15.6 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 37.4s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps +12.6 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 39.42s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "response" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "earsb" (overlap 0.31). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 43.9s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps +13.7 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 43.9s | skin-tone | unknown | skin NOT JUDGED: the shot from 43.9s to 45.2s sits a*+0.0 b*+3.3 from the other shots (distance 3.3). The donor reaches 7.1 at its own cuts, so this scale cannot separate a light change from a skin change. A human decides; positive a* and b* together read as warmer and more yellow. | | 45.2s | skin-tone | unknown | skin NOT JUDGED: the shot from 45.2s to 46.73s sits a*+1.1 b*-3.8 from the other shots (distance 4.9). The donor reaches 7.1 at its own cuts, so this scale cannot separate a light change from a skin change. A human decides; positive a* and b* together read as warmer and more yellow. | | 46.73s | skin-tone | unknown | skin NOT JUDGED: the shot from 46.73s to 50.2s sits a*+0.6 b*-4.0 from the other shots (distance 5.7). The donor reaches 7.1 at its own cuts, so this scale cannot separate a light change from a skin change. A human decides; positive a* and b* together read as warmer and more yellow. | | 53.3s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "irritating" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "ra" (overlap 0.33). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 62.16s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "anything" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "or ayh" (overlap 0.46). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 63.48s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "irritation" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "azrt" (overlap 0.29). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 66.93s | skin-tone | unknown | skin NOT JUDGED: the shot from 66.93s to 68.73s sits a*+0.4 b*-4.5 from the other shots (distance 7.0). The donor reaches 7.1 at its own cuts, so this scale cannot separate a light change from a skin change. A human decides; positive a* and b* together read as warmer and more yellow. | | 68.733s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps +158.0 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 70.56s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "especially" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "ec" (overlap 0.33). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 73.333s | audio-seam | unknown | the track steps -19.3 dB here, and one side of the cut is silence, so this is a speaker starting or stopping rather than a seam in the sound | | 73.82s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "actually" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "afsi" (overlap 0.17). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 74.78s | pronunciation | unknown | REDUB SHORTLIST: "coachella" is heard by an acoustic model with no vocabulary as "tcuchal" (overlap 0.5). Whisper reports the right word because its language model supplies it. The donor control slurs its own words to 0.38, so this is a ranking for a human, not a verdict. | | 85.386s | audio | unknown | 1 click(s) away from any cut, reported only: 85.386s |