# QA — c002-remake (stage: final) 10 fatal, 5 major, 0 minor, 0 cosmetic (cosmetic = a viewer cannot see it at full speed) | At | Kind | Severity | Notice | What | |---|---|---|---|---| | 2.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Bright solid pink tracking card is the focus of the shot as it is placed into a handbag. This is not the approved black reference product, it is an incorrect/competitor product held centre frame. | | 5.0s | hands | fatal | 3 | Hands interacting with the phone have extra distorted fused fingers, impossible human hand anatomy, clearly visible as the main action of this shot. | | 9.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Bright pink tracking card is held next to the phone as the shot focus, it is not the required black reference product. Also on-screen phone text reads the competitor product name 'Spotminders Tracking Card'. | | 18.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Bright pink tracking card is placed into a wallet, centre frame clear focus, this is not the approved black product. | | 21.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Bright pink tracking card is placed on a wireless charger as the entire shot focus, this is an incorrect product. | | 23.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Woman holds incorrect branded product packaging and displays the pink wrong product alongside a competitor black card; none match the reference product. | | 24.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Man holds a grey incorrect tracking card plus the bright pink wrong tracking card, neither matches the approved black reference product, held directly to camera. | | 25.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Multiple wrong tracking cards are displayed: pink card, and branded black cards that do not match the plain black reference product, held as the shot focus. | | 28.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Bright pink tracking card is shown being placed into a handbag, clear focus of the shot, incorrect product. | | 30.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Woman holds the bright pink incorrect tracking card directly to camera, it is the sole focus of this shot, not the reference product. | | 0.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Black tracking card has printed foreign branded text on its right edge; the reference product is plain unmarked black, this text is clearly visible. | | 7.0s | text | major | 2 | Text on the phone screen is reversed mirrored garbled unreadable text, displayed on the active phone interface. | | 11.0s | text | major | 2 | All map location labels on the phone screen are nonsensical garbled random text with no real readable place names. | | 29.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Black tracking card shown has printed illegible branding text on its surface, does not match the plain unmarked reference black product. | | 34.0s | text | major | 2 | Tracking app screen on the phone has all interface text as nonsensical garbled unreadable text. | ## What the video says It's been in my handbag for 186 days, and I haven't charged it once. Setup runs through Apple Find My, already on every iPhone. My granddaughter held the card near mine, tapped a couple of buttons, and the map showed my handbag sitting in the kitchen. That was the last time I thought about it. At 1.8 millimeters thin, the card disappears inside my wallet, and the battery has held up for eight months with no reminder. Over 500,000. The Buy 2, Get 1 free deal is running right now. backpack and for the sister who keeps asking about yours. 100 day return window is still there if the setup trips you up. ## The reviewer, in full ``` [ {"t": 0.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Black tracking card has printed foreign branded text on its right edge; the reference product is plain unmarked black, this text is clearly visible."}, {"t": 2.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Bright solid pink tracking card is the focus of the shot as it is placed into a handbag. This is not the approved black reference product, it is an incorrect/competitor product held centre frame."}, {"t": 5.0, "kind": "hands", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Hands interacting with the phone have extra distorted fused fingers, impossible human hand anatomy, clearly visible as the main action of this shot."}, {"t": 7.0, "kind": "text", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Text on the phone screen is reversed mirrored garbled unreadable text, displayed on the active phone interface."}, {"t": 9.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Bright pink tracking card is held next to the phone as the shot focus, it is not the required black reference product. Also on-screen phone text reads the competitor product name 'Spotminders Tracking Card'."}, {"t": 11.0, "kind": "text", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "All map location labels on the phone screen are nonsensical garbled random text with no real readable place names."}, {"t": 18.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Bright pink tracking card is placed into a wallet, centre frame clear focus, this is not the approved black product."}, {"t": 21.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Bright pink tracking card is placed on a wireless charger as the entire shot focus, this is an incorrect product."}, {"t": 23.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Woman holds incorrect branded product packaging and displays the pink wrong product alongside a competitor black card; none match the reference product."}, {"t": 24.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Man holds a grey incorrect tracking card plus the bright pink wrong tracking card, neither matches the approved black reference product, held directly to camera."}, {"t": 25.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Multiple wrong tracking cards are displayed: pink card, and branded black cards that do not match the plain black reference product, held as the shot focus."}, {"t": 28.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Bright pink tracking card is shown being placed into a handbag, clear focus of the shot, incorrect product."}, {"t": 29.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Black tracking card shown has printed illegible branding text on its surface, does not match the plain unmarked reference black product."}, {"t": 30.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Woman holds the bright pink incorrect tracking card directly to camera, it is the sole focus of this shot, not the reference product."}, {"t": 34.0, "kind": "text", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Tracking app screen on the phone has all interface text as nonsensical garbled unreadable text."} ] ```