<!-- copy: internal — QA verdict for c002-remake-cap, machine-written, not ad copy -->

# QA — c002-remake-cap (stage: final)

8 fatal, 3 major, 0 minor, 0 cosmetic (cosmetic = a viewer cannot see it at full speed)

| At | Kind | Severity | Notice | What |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Competitor pink tracking card is shown being placed into a handbag, clearly in centre frame. This is not the approved black product from reference image 1. |
| 19.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Pink competitor tracking card is shown being inserted into a wallet, clear centre frame view, not the approved black product. |
| 22.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Pink competitor tracking card is held on a charging pad, clearly visible centre frame, incorrect product. |
| 25.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | A man holds the pink competitor tracking card up on camera alongside other unapproved cards, full clear view. |
| 26.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Pink competitor tracking card is laid on the desk in a hero product shot, fully visible. |
| 27.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Pink competitor tracking card is held up to camera in a product demonstration shot. |
| 28.0s | identity | fatal | 3 | After a cut, the main presenter is replaced with an entirely different woman: a caucasian grey-haired woman in a green sweater, which is not the approved reference actress from image 2 that was used for all prior presenter shots. This was intended to be the same continuous character. |
| 32.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Pink competitor tracking card is held directly to the camera by the blonde woman, centre frame clear view. |
| 5.0s | hands | major | 2 | Distorted extra fingers are visible on the hands interacting with the phone; unnatural wrong hand anatomy is plainly visible. |
| 7.0s | text | major | 2 | All text displayed on the iPhone screen is reversed / mirrored backwards, unreadable invalid text. |
| 36.0s | text | major | 2 | Phone interface displays garbled nonsense invalid text instead of proper readable UI content. |

## What the video says

It's been in my handbag for 186 days, and I haven't charged it once.  Setup runs through Apple Find My, already on every iPhone.  My granddaughter held the card near mine, tapped a couple of buttons,  and the map showed my handbag sitting in the kitchen.  That was the last time I thought about it.  At 1.8 millimeters thin, the card disappears inside my wallet,  and the battery has held up for eight months with no reminder.  Over 500,000.  The Buy 2, Get 1 free deal is running right now.  backpack and for the sister who keeps asking about yours. 100 day return window is still there if the setup trips you up.

## The reviewer, in full

```
[
{"t":2.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Competitor pink tracking card is shown being placed into a handbag, clearly in centre frame. This is not the approved black product from reference image 1."},
{"t":5.0,"kind":"hands","notice":2,"severity":"major","at_a_cut":false,"what":"Distorted extra fingers are visible on the hands interacting with the phone; unnatural wrong hand anatomy is plainly visible."},
{"t":7.0,"kind":"text","notice":2,"severity":"major","at_a_cut":false,"what":"All text displayed on the iPhone screen is reversed / mirrored backwards, unreadable invalid text."},
{"t":19.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Pink competitor tracking card is shown being inserted into a wallet, clear centre frame view, not the approved black product."},
{"t":22.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Pink competitor tracking card is held on a charging pad, clearly visible centre frame, incorrect product."},
{"t":25.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"A man holds the pink competitor tracking card up on camera alongside other unapproved cards, full clear view."},
{"t":26.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Pink competitor tracking card is laid on the desk in a hero product shot, fully visible."},
{"t":27.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Pink competitor tracking card is held up to camera in a product demonstration shot."},
{"t":28.0,"kind":"identity","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"After a cut, the main presenter is replaced with an entirely different woman: a caucasian grey-haired woman in a green sweater, which is not the approved reference actress from image 2 that was used for all prior presenter shots. This was intended to be the same continuous character."},
{"t":32.0,"kind":"wrong-product","notice":3,"severity":"fatal","at_a_cut":true,"what":"Pink competitor tracking card is held directly to the camera by the blonde woman, centre frame clear view."},
{"t":36.0,"kind":"text","notice":2,"severity":"major","at_a_cut":false,"what":"Phone interface displays garbled nonsense invalid text instead of proper readable UI content."}
]
```