<!-- copy: internal — QA verdict for c001-remake-cap, machine-written, not ad copy -->

# QA — c001-remake-cap (stage: final)

2 fatal, 9 major, 0 minor, 0 cosmetic (cosmetic = a viewer cannot see it at full speed)

| At | Kind | Severity | Notice | What |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8.0s | wrong-product | fatal | 3 | Competitor pink Spotminders tracking card is held up to a phone, displayed centre frame. This is not our black reference product, this is the forbidden competitor product. |
| 19.0s | identity | fatal | 3 | During a continuous uncut talking shot, the main actress changes entirely: her glasses disappear, hair texture/shape changes, and facial features become a different woman with no cut between frames. |
| 0.0s | text | major | 3 | On-screen caption incorrectly reads 'I'm the last person in my bridge' - the line is incorrectly truncated, missing the 'club' word that is spoken, and this is the opening spoken line. |
| 2.0s | text | major | 2 | Product packaging text is misspelled as 'Tarking Card' instead of the correct 'Tracking Card' on the displayed box. |
| 18.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Pink competitor tracking card is placed into a wallet, clear view of the incorrect product. |
| 21.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Pink competitor tracking card is placed on a wireless charging pad, the forbidden product is shown. |
| 23.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Packaging for the pink competitor tracking card is held up directly to camera. |
| 24.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | An actor holds the pink competitor tracking card up to the camera for demonstration. |
| 25.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | The pink competitor tracking card is laid on the table alongside our correct black products. |
| 26.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | The pink competitor tracking card is held and shown centre frame in the product demonstration shot. |
| 29.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | The pink competitor tracking card is placed into a handbag during the usage demonstration. |

## What the video says

I'm the last person in my bridge club who'd buy a gadget, and I did.  Setup runs through Apple Find My, already on every iPhone.  My granddaughter held the card near mine, tapped a couple of buttons,  and the map showed my handbag sitting in the kitchen.  That was the last time I thought about it.  At 1.8 millimeters thin, the card disappears inside my wallet,  and the battery has held up for eight months with no reminder.  Over 500,000 of us carry one of us.  The Buy 2, Get 1 free deal is running right now.  sister who keeps asking about yours.  The 100-day return window is still there if the setup trips you up.

## The reviewer, in full

```
[
  {"t": 0.0, "kind": "text", "notice": 3, "severity": "major", "what": "On-screen caption incorrectly reads 'I'm the last person in my bridge' - the line is incorrectly truncated, missing the 'club' word that is spoken, and this is the opening spoken line."},
  {"t": 2.0, "kind": "text", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Product packaging text is misspelled as 'Tarking Card' instead of the correct 'Tracking Card' on the displayed box."},
  {"t": 8.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "what": "Competitor pink Spotminders tracking card is held up to a phone, displayed centre frame. This is not our black reference product, this is the forbidden competitor product."},
  {"t": 18.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Pink competitor tracking card is placed into a wallet, clear view of the incorrect product."},
  {"t": 19.0, "kind": "identity", "notice": 3, "severity": "fatal", "at_a_cut": false, "what": "During a continuous uncut talking shot, the main actress changes entirely: her glasses disappear, hair texture/shape changes, and facial features become a different woman with no cut between frames."},
  {"t": 21.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Pink competitor tracking card is placed on a wireless charging pad, the forbidden product is shown."},
  {"t": 23.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "Packaging for the pink competitor tracking card is held up directly to camera."},
  {"t": 24.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "An actor holds the pink competitor tracking card up to the camera for demonstration."},
  {"t": 25.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "The pink competitor tracking card is laid on the table alongside our correct black products."},
  {"t": 26.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "The pink competitor tracking card is held and shown centre frame in the product demonstration shot."},
  {"t": 29.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "what": "The pink competitor tracking card is placed into a handbag during the usage demonstration."}
]
```